Saturday, April 18, 2015

I love recruitment: Rejecting CVs is so much fun



Most recruiters these days get a plenty of CVs from their professional ‘çontacts’ and otherwise. Thanks to some boom in social networking space, getting details of a recruitment person is not difficult- first name.last name@company name.com and bingo, you got the correct email id too. Absolutely no rocket science.

I am not sure how many unsolicited CVs a recruitment person gets in a day. Especially if one is into IT service sector or an e-commerce company. And if you and the applicant have a shared contact on any of the social media site, you cannot even call the CV received as an unsolicited one- even though you have not spoken to your contact in years. Just to give an idea, during my tenure in recruitment with an IT service major, we used to get almost 20-30 thousand resumes in a quarter through our career email id and that too when social media was way less active.

We all know that the ratios are pathetic if we take unemployed population to the eligible for hiring population and unemployed population and available openings. Hence as a recruitment person, I looked for all possible reasons to reject- a slightest doubt, any ambiguity, irrelevant or incomplete information and sometimes even presentation of CV. Scientifically proven, an average Human’s attention span is less than 3 minutes. With modern technology like internet and multi-channel dish TVs, the attention span of humans has reduced drastically as people quickly move to another available option if they do not find one channel/ website appealing. Gone are the days of only Doordarshan where people had no choice but to look at that round thing revolving. 

So let me tell you my favorite reasons to reject CVs.
Ah that cut-copy-paste: I have seen many CVs where people have copied project details from a colleague’s CV. Trust me I have even seen people from different backgrounds in terms of caste and state having the date of birth and father’s name same as each other (thanks to Indian caste system, it makes job easier for recruiters by proving this plagiarism). Obviously, none made to the interview round.

During world-war 2, a famous German spy was caught with a fake British passport. The reason was most simple and it was just one minor mistake which the Germans did despite copying it to a near perfection. Germans of that era, used to write the numeric seven as 7 while the Britishers wrote it as 7. In a similar way, lot of people while copying, miss out on matching the font and style of writing. You may notice two paragraphs in different fonts and writing styles. Bang on!! Recruiters have one reason to drop a CV as probability of being fake is high.

CV is not encyclopedia: I wonder sometimes what must have been the thought process of a person with 5-8 years of relevant job experience when he writes that he was the class cricket team captain or an event coordinator of a college festival during his under-grads. Baffles me. Rather beats me! Some also do not shy away from mentioning their graduation projects while they are applying for a mid-management role. In the sea of irrelevant information, the relevant ones get lost. As a professional, I would like to focus on your professional quality for which I am going to hire you and personal qualities which holds relevance for me in terms of organizational and team fitment. Nothing beyond. 
Senior level people also fall into certain common mistakes which they shall avoid. A long encyclopedia CV and lack of clarity on role they have been performing or they want to get into often lead to rejection or holding of CV. Sometimes, their best work just gets lost in a resume of almost 6-8 pages. It is almost like finding a needle in hay-stack

What do you want to do?: I had the unique experience of knowing one gentleman- of course through his CV. I knew him so well that after a point just by seeing the sender’s name, I used to move the mail to the junk folder. The person applied to all possible jobs we used to advertise in newspaper and send application for all of them. Right from Java architect, dot net programmer to program manager, he was everything. This omnipotent man surely caught the attention of all recruiters but for wrong reasons. The CV shall speak in the introductory paragraph, that who you are and where would you like to go. Selective applications will yield more success than carpet bombing.

Hiding information- something fishy:
My award for best academic qualification goes to BE from JNTU. It really helped me a lot in dropping off the CVs. Nothing against any university but during late 2000s, lot of fake colleges mushroomed and used to give fake degrees. Most of them used JNTU’s name which otherwise is a prestigious university in Andhra. Hence to avoid the trap of false information and fake degrees, recruiters between 2008 and 2010 started rejecting JNTU CVs unless college, marks and other relevant details were mentioned. The tenth and twelfth marks actually helped in establishing the credibility of one’s academic orientation. 

Same way if an application shows experience of ten years but employment details mentioned are only for 5-6 years or a gap in education or employment is left unexplained, no recruitment person will have the bandwidth to get the relevant information individually from all the applied candidates at the initial level of screening.

I have talked a lot about how recruiters drop CV. That doesn’t mean that recruiters are only to reject people. Imagine an ‘ Indian Idol ’competition going on and poor three judges have to go through auditions of thousands of people to have top first top twenty five and then the winner. The audition round is more of elimination and finding the champion from top twenty odd people is the selection. Recruitment is no different. In elimination round, with attention span of judge being just 30-60 seconds, one needs to strike the right chord and right node within the given time. There is no second chance. So what is the right chord and node for your candidature?

  • Be precise: A two-three sider CV will catch more attention than an eight pager.
  • Provide information: Give details about your education, college and experience with relevant dates. For senior profiles, education scores may not matter much but for fresh out of college people, surely it is one of the selection criteria. Do not assume that by hiding, you can get away as all companies will have their policies around.
  •  Do not hide information: Breaks between two jobs are better admitted than left unaddressed.
  •  Do not twist information: In cases where you have worked in an organization for a month or two only, do not try to merge the experience to show stability in your career. If found later on in background verification process, be sure you will lose the job because of discrepancy.
  • Provide relevant information: Provide information about your current job and responsibilities. As you progress in your career, your recent jobs shall have more weightage on your CV and previous ones shall shrink appropriately.
  • Basic personal information is needed: Contact information, date of birth, passport status are always helpful.
  • Do not copy: Even if your friend and you are working in same project, present differently. Your CV is reflection of your style of presenting the facts. Do not copy.
  • Claim what you have done: A false claim can fall flat in interview and it will be worse than not having the tall claims.


In short, keep it simple and be honest.